Skip to Content

Peanut and pumpkin butter apple sandwich

Peanut butter, pumpkin butter and apple sandwich. A unique, crunchy and flavorful combination for all your autumn cravings.

Peanut butter, pumpkin butter and apple sandwich. A unique, crunchy and flavorful combination for all your autumn cravings.

Okay, you guys *may* think I'm a little weird for this one, but I think it deserves a post.

It all started when I was trying to find other uses for my scrumptious pumpkin butter.

There really wasn't much I could find about what goes with pumpkin butter on a sandwich. Even more reason for me to share it! But I remembered I used to make peanut butter and apple butter sandwiches, so why not just use peanut butter and real apples with the pumpkin butter?!

It all seemed to go together at the time.

It was actually really good, though if you are a weird one that doesn't like PB&J's then this probably isn't for you (sorry, mom).

Peanut butter, pumpkin butter, and apple sandwich. A unique, crunchy and flavorful combination for all your autumn cravings.

I used country white bread, which I rarely ever buy but any kind of white bread or fluffy bread would work well. Now that I think about it, challah bread would be delicious for this pumpkin butter apple sandwich.

I don't think it would work as well with wheat or whole grain bread, but let me know if you try it.

Peanut butter, pumpkin butter, and apple sandwich. A unique, crunchy and flavorful combination for all your autumn cravings.

I added a little cinnamon for flavor too.

Peanut butter, pumpkin butter, and apple sandwich. A unique, crunchy and flavorful combination for all your autumn cravings.

Peanut butter, pumpkin butter, and apple sandwich. A unique, crunchy and flavorful combination for all your autumn cravings.

Even though this doesn't sound like a traditional sandwich, it still makes me feel like it should go in a little kid's lunchbox. You can cut the crusts off, too, if you really want to add to the effect!

Any other Fall or Autumn flavored sandwiches you think I should try? Let me know in the comments!

Useful and recommended items for this peanut butter, pumpkin butter and apple sandwich recipe:

Peanut and pumpkin butter apple sandwich
Print Pin
5 from 1 vote

Peanut and pumpkin butter apple sandwich

Peanut butter, pumpkin butter, and apple sandwich. A unique, crunchy and flavorful combination for all your autumn cravings.
Course Main Course
Cuisine American
Prep Time 5 minutes
Total Time 5 minutes
Servings 1
Author Kelly @ Trial and Eater

Ingredients

  • 2 slices country white bread (or vegan bread if necessary)
  • 1 tablespoon peanut butter , or desired amount
  • 1 tablespoon pumpkin butter , or desired amount
  • 1/2 apple sliced
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon

Instructions

  • Spread peanut butter over one piece of bread, and add sliced apples on top.
  • Spread pumpkin butter over the other piece of bread.
  • Sprinkle cinnamon over either or both sides of bread.
  • Combine and enjoy!

Peanut butter, pumpkin butter, and apple sandwich. A unique, crunchy and flavorful combination for all your autumn cravings.

*There are links within this post that we can earn a commission on at no extra cost to you (known as affiliate links). Thank you for helping to support the site!

Slightly sweet cranberry sauce
Previous
Slightly sweet cranberry sauce
Coconut snowball cookies are the perfect festive treat for the holidays, Christmas parties and gifts. Only 4 ingredients needed!
Next
Coconut snowballs

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Brian Duda

Wednesday 23rd of October 2019

Nice post

Hollie

Saturday 16th of April 2016

I was wondering if anybody turned this into a stuffed french toast? If not, do you think it would work?

Kelly

Monday 18th of April 2016

I think that's a great idea Hollie! Let me know if you try it :)