Skip to Content

Misfits Market Review

This post contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission if you make a purchase after clicking on my links. All opinions are my own.

Trial and Eater’s review of the organic produce delivery service, Misfits Market.

**Please note that the below was written before Misfits changed how they do boxes. They now have a add-what-you-want policy and no longer do mixed boxes.**

Ready to buy and don’t need to see the review? Head on over here to enter your zip code and get started.

[the_ad id=’12362′]

Always affordable, occasionally funny-looking Misfits Market box

What’s a Misfits Box?

Misfits Market is an organic produce delivery company that was created to reduce food waste. The fruits and vegetables are mostly “misfits” – meaning they are oddly shaped or may have other small quirks. Misfits doesn’t really mean ugly produce from my experience – it’s often just a size difference.

Natural imperfections or unusual sizes of produce mean many supermarkets don’t want them – and that’s where Misfits comes in. They “rescue” this produce, and other excess from farms, and ship it directly to your home.

Sometimes they also source “normal” produce from other places that have excess that will not be used, so it may have stickers on it or containers that look like it came from a grocery store.

close up of misfits market veggies, carrots in center


Misfits has one of the best priced organic veggie boxes I’ve tried. I’m really quite impressed with the value!

There are two size options: Mischief (small) or Madness (large), priced at $22 or $35 for 12-14 types of fruits and vegetables.

Shipping is $5.50 on each box.

Below is an example photo of all the produce from a “Madness Box”! It lets you choose 14 kinds of produce from a few groups of options, and you have the option to add-on more from the marketplace.

example of Misfits Market "madness" produce box

What’s in a Box

You have the option to customize your boxes based on your preferences, but generally there will be room for 12-14 different fruits and veggies.

If you don’t choose your options or click a box that says “surprise me”, it will be filled with a variety of whatever they have.

My first box was a variety and included broccoli, cherry tomatoes, carrots, blueberries, bell peppers, parsley, beets, several kinds of potatoes, celery, apples, onion, pears, pomegranate and more.

example of Misfits Market "madness" produce box

Another example of a large Madness box, from my cousin who I convinced to buy! They went heavy on the greens, and had a couple additions from the marketplace like the turmeric tea.

example of Misfits Market "madness" produce box

Misfits Marketplace

With a Misfits membership you also gain access to their “marketplace” where you can choose to add-on items to any box.

Lots of cool items to choose from! I received some coffee, pasta, cooking oil, superfood granola, toffee and cashews. There are also juices, spices, baking supplies, snacks and even extra produce.

In other boxes I’ve also snagged great deals on bread, snack bars and other pantry items. The options fluctuate week to week.

example of Misfits Marketplace pantry items order - canola oil, pasta, coffee, granola, toffee and cashew

How it Works

On the Misfits home page you’ll first enter your zip code and email to make sure you’re within the delivery area.

Once you sign up, you’ll pick your delivery day and initial frequency of your box (weekly or every other week – don’t worry, you can change this later!).

A few days before your box will be shipped, you’ll get to “build your box.” There are several sections of fruits and vegetables where you can pick a certain amount from that group of options, based on availability.

Then you will be able to see what’s available in the Marketplace, if you’d like to add on any other items. You have a few days to confirm this, but items may run out if you don’t choose quick!

Other things to know

If you ever want to skip a delivery you can easily do so within your online account. Another cool feature is that you can choose to donate your paid box to a food bank, as an easy way to give back to the community.

The packaging itself is also very eco-friendly. Not only are the boxes recyclable, but the insulation used to keep the produce cold (mostly used in warmer month) is recyclable is as well.

Since the produce can arrive a little bumped or bruised, it doesn’t last super long. Especially since it’s organic, you’ll want to be prepared with a plan for your produce once it arrives!

Currently, they deliver to 34 states mostly in the Eastern part of the U.S. You can enter your zip code to see availability in your area from the Misfits website.

example of Misfits Market "madness" produce box

Review Summary

Overall, I’ve been really enjoying my Misfits Market delivery boxes. Even though I received my first box as a gift, I’ve been a paying subscriber for months now and have referred many family members on to it already.

There are some downsides: issues with shipping or broken items in my boxes, though customer service is usually very helpful about refunding any unusable produce. I do think they have room for improvement in how they package their boxes, as sometimes heavy marketplace add-ons are on top of delicate produce or aren’t separated correctly. There was one time an ice pack broke and got over everything.

Though I have to say the greens are some of the freshest I’ve ever eaten, and I do get excited to try items that I wouldn’t normally find in a store – like dandelion greens, candy cane beets, different varieties of fruit. And some weeks there are great deals on marketplace items.

The large “Madness” box is great to try for your first box and get as much variety as you can, especially if you use a discount code for the first box. After that, you can always switch to the smaller box if you decide that would be more manageable for your household.

I find the large box is a much better deal, so even as a smaller household I still get the large box just once or twice a month. I’m able to share extra produce if I don’t think I’ll be able to eat it in time, and it kind of forces me to eat more vegetables when I have more fresh options on hand.

Not only does it help me be a little more creative in the kitchen, but it is a great value with a well-intentioned mission behind it.

If they deliver to your state, I definitely recommend giving them a try! Head on over to enter your zip code to see availability and get started. If they’re not in your area yet, you can add yourself to the waitlist.

Thanks for reading our Misfits Market review! Will you try a Misfits box? Or snap a pic and share on Instagram and tag @trialandeater to show me what you got!

Eat Delicious, Eat Misfits. Misfits Market box

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Katherine Grant

Thursday 3rd of December 2020

Thank you for turning me on to Misfits! 2nd box will arrive on Saturday and we are looking forward to it :)


Saturday 5th of December 2020

I love it when I find things like this that are helpful, I'm so glad you are enjoying it :)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.